Divisions Calculations Are Wrong


[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ SoCalHoops Womens Forum ] [ FAQ ]

Posted by POS on June 08, 2019 at 22:20:12:

So I was told to prove that the person posting the divisions and 2-year team point totals on this site that there were inaccuracies with his totals even though I already proved that this person was wrong once. But this person feels that they are as close to accurate as possible and that the information being shared is in fact correct and should be trusted. I have repeatedly said that the totals being given were more than likely over 50% inaccurate.
So here's what I did. I looked at all the teams that this person posted results on this site. There were 88 teams to look at. I checked all 88 teams using what was posted on the CIF-SS schedule and results page for every team. This is the information that CIF will use to determine each team's point totals for this year and for the 2-year total. Here is the link to the page just in case anyone likes to take a look at where I got my information. https://cifss.org/sports/girls-basketball/schedule-results/
I will post the team and this person's results and then my results right next to theirs. I have double-checked my numbers and they are correct. I contacted some coaches and they confirmed my totals. I went to a friend who is doing his own division calculations and he confirmed that my numbers matched his.

So here is what I have:

Northview 14.446 14.464 Spot On
Covina 12.195 12.304 Off
San Dimas 11.23 11.286 Close
Rowland 10.139 10.135 Spot On
HH Wilson 6.5 6.5 Spot On
St. Genevieve 8.026 7.8785 Off
St. Pius/Matthias 7.757 7.8858 Kinda
Mary Star 6.53 6.6411 Kinda
Sonora 18.235 18.802 Off
Flintridge Prep 17.536 17.59 Close
Bur. Providence 10.406 10.34 Kinda
Chadwick 9.671 9.670 Spot On
Pasadena Poly 8.914 8.910 Spot On
Mayfield 7.281 7.6933 Off
Rio Hondo Prep 6.629 6.692 Kinda
St. Mary's Acad. 19.604 20.66 Off
St. Paul 17.242 17.119 Kinda
St. Joseph 9.959 10.340 Off
La Salle 9.688 9.527 Kinda
St. Monica 5.874 6.1629 Off
Mark Keppel 22.067 21.689 Off
San Gabriel 10.347 11.075 Off
Bell Gardens 10.582 11.225 Off
Montebello 9.998 10.104 Kinda
Schurr 8.12 8.414 Off
Alhambra 7.336 6.983 Off
LB Poly 21.732 21.36 Off
LB Millikan 16.884 16.87 Spot On
Lakewood 14.651 14.66 Spot On
LB Wilson 11.066 10.786 Off
Compton 9.98 9.827 Kinda
LB Jordan 7.233 7.2669 Kinda
LB Cabrillo 7.208 7.6849 Off
Mater Dei 33.881 35.400 Off
Rosary 25.419 26.522 Off
Orange Lutheran 21.856 20.48 Off
Santa Margarita 18.824 19.251 Off
JSerra 18.338 18.60 Off
Huntington Beach 19.46 19.474 Spot On
Los Alamitos 21.844 21.04 Off
Corona del Mar 13.015 12.784 Off
Edison 12.084 12.112 Close
Etiwanda 30.703 31.011 Off
Los Osos 18.728 19.01 Off
Chino Hills 18.465 19.51 Off
Upland 15.863 15.24 Off
Rancho Cucamonga 15.51 15.51 Spot On
St. Lucy's 7.171 7.4703 Off
Culver City 15.874 15.875 Spot On
El Segundo 13.316 13.48 Kinda
Santa Monica 11.87 11.408 Off
Beverly Hills 10.27 10.79 Off
Lawndale 6.491 6.561 Close
Saugus 18.642 19.203 Off
Valencia 18.252 18.11 Kinda
CC Canyon 16.722 16.61 Kinda
Hart 10.633 10.729 Kinda
Golden Valley 9.023 9.013 Spot On
West Ranch 7.067 7.197 Kinda
Village Christian 17.386 17.148 Off
Maranatha 14.206 13.88 Off
Whittier Christian 13.403 14.051 Off
Valley Christian 10.284 10.34 Close
Heritage Christian 8.495 8.386 Kinda
Crean Lutheran 12.171 12.155 Close
Hillcrest 11.775 11.81 Close
Orange Vista 9.416 9.241 Off
Garey 9.282 9.2809 Spot On
Xavier Prep 8.723 8.639 Close
Anaheim 10.083 10.496 Off
Moreno Valley 9.162 9.311 Off
Arcadia 18.159 18.28 Kinda
Pasadena 16.407 16.41 Close
Crescenta Valley 15.923 16.15 Off
Bur. Burroughs 15.861 15.721 Kinda
Glendale 12.848 12.851 Spot On
Burbank 11.656 11.656 Spot On
Hoover 7.489 7.363 Kinda
Rosemead 11.179 11.066 Kinda
Gabrielino 10.104 9.798 Off
Arroyo 7.902 7.782 Kinda
Marshall 6.965 7.5163 Off
Redondo Union 27.4 27.4 Spot On
Palos Verdes 16.934 17.532 Off
Peninsula 15.64 15.22 Off
Leuzinger 15.051 15.051 Spot On
Mira Costa 14.41 13.67 Off
Compton Centennial 7.216 7.2163 Spot On

If anyone has any questions about my results I will show you how I got my totals. As for the person posting the results and the divisions according to my numbers you were off or not even close on 42 teams or 47%. 17 teams you got spot on correct or 19%. 9 teams you were close on and 20 teams that you missed on by more than a tenth.

So this should show that the information provided by this person is extremely inaccurate and should not be used for anything regarding where teams are placed in divisions. There are huge discrepancies in the totals that will move teams from the divisions that his person posted. This person has never shown how he got his point totals. I showed how I got Palos Verdes total and this person admitted that he was wrong but still he goes on posting that he is correct that his numbers are spot on. What do you have to say now? I can't wait to hear the excuses about how his numbers are correct and mine are wrong.



Follow Ups:



Post a Followup

Name:
E-Mail:

Subject:

Comments:

Optional Link URL:
Link Title:
Optional Image URL:


[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ SoCalHoops Womens Forum ] [ FAQ ]