Re: Coaches Polls

[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ Mens Message Forum ] [ FAQ ]

Posted by Records on January 11, 2017 at 19:25:32:

In Reply to: Re: Coaches Polls posted by But on January 11, 2017 at 18:08:34:

: : : : : : Team A is ranked higher than Team B in the Preseason Coaches Poll

: : : : : : Team A then beats Team B

: : : : : : Latest Coaches poll has Team B ranked higher than Team A

: : : : : Go to Max Preps and look on their "playoff prediction" calculator....that gives a better idea of who should be ranked where based on record, head to head matchups, and strength of schedule

: : : : MaxPreps is not as strong as the freeman ratings were. Coaches' polls are usually manipulated, especially in the lower divisions.

: : : The last polls were several weeks ago. Plenty of other games can impact the placement.

: : Which games should matter the most in a poll or ranking? I would think a head to head match up would take top priority but then again Ohio State went to the 4 team College Football playoff over a team they lost to (Penn St) and then were shut out in the Fiesta Bowl. Maybe those other games are not AS important as the head to head match up.

: I agree head to head matters. But if the team that won lost 3 other games during the time period... it is hard to make a blanket statement with the facts given.

Records by individual teams in a section with 550 teams is pretty irrelevant. A team who plays a tough schedule maybe .500 while the team they beat head to head may have an easier schedule and win 75% of their games. Who cares if one wins more than the other, you cannot just look at win/loss records when doing the poll you also have to consider who they play to get that record. I've seen numerous times in the playoffs where a team has an inflated record and loses early because they do not play playoff caliber teams during the regular season. Too often coaches voting in the poll do not see past a number that suggests a lot wins but was earned by playing low level competition.

Follow Ups:

Post a Followup




Optional Link URL:
Link Title:
Optional Image URL:

[ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ] [ Mens Message Forum ] [ FAQ ]